Principal Oversteps Authority ?

What a student does in a classroom and on school
property is one thing but outside on a public sidewalk
is another. This principal should have known where to
draw the line. So yes I think the student's right to free
speech were badly trampled on by the school principal.
People in positions of authority should be aware of where
their powers begin and end. What's your opinion on this
issue. Read the article below and offer up your comments.


High school students may have a right to free speech, but that does not include the freedom to unfurl a banner promoting "bong hits" during a school activity, the Supreme Court was told Monday. An unusual case from Alaska tests whether principals and teachers can punish students for banners, buttons or other messages that conflict with the goals and policies set by school officials. During Monday's argument, former U.S. Solicitor General Kenneth W. Starr and a Bush administration attorney urged the justices to defer to school officials when deciding what messages were appropriate on and around a high school campus.

"Illegal drugs and the glorification of the drug culture are profoundly serious problems for our nation," said Starr, dean of Pepperdine University School of Law. He represents a school principal from Juneau, Alaska, who was sued for ripping away the banner and suspending the student who unfurled it. Permitting the banner to be displayed would be "interpreted as an encouragement of the drug culture," Starr said. Deputy Solicitor General Edwin Kneedler, representing the Justice Department, added, "A school does not have to tolerate a message that is inconsistent with its basic educational mission."

But a lawyer representing the student said the right to free speech should prevail so long as the message did not disrupt classrooms or the education process. "This is a case about free speech. It is not a case about drugs," said Douglas K. Mertz, a lawyer from Juneau. His client, Joseph Frederick, was an 18-year-old senior in 2002 when the torch for the Winter Olympics was scheduled to pass in front of the high school. Frederick was standing on a public street as the TV cameras came into range. He and several other students then unfurled the 14-foot banner that said, "Bong Hits 4 Jesus."

The school's principal, Deborah Morse, ripped it away from the students and sent Frederick to the office. She planned to suspend him for five days, but when he invoked Thomas Jefferson and the 1st Amendment, she doubled the suspension to 10 days. Frederick sued, alleging Morse had violated his constitutional rights. A federal judge rejected his claim, but the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco ruled for the student and said the principal could be forced to pay damages.





This Article Continues Here:





Get your copy of the award winning King:
"From Atlanta to the Mountain top
It's the 3-Hour Docudrama that
ells the story of the Civil Rights
movement and the life of its
rum Major for Peace,
Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.
To learn more and hear
excerpts from this treasured
program,click here:
http://www.kingprogram.net/